The Efficacy of the Retirement Pension Provision System: Modeling, and Assessing of the Case of Kazakhstan

Abstract

This research is aimed at developing a methodology for assessing the e cacy of a macroeconomic model of the Kazakhstani pension provision system. A hierarchy of indicators of the pension system e cacy is built using the graph method. The representativeness of these indicators is confirmed by using expert assessment and factor analysis. A multi-factor assessment model is built using an additive convolution of the normalized values of the 2014–2019 resulting indicators with a breakdown by regions, regarding the coe cients of their significance. A regression model is developed to show the dependence of the pension system e cacy on the share of the accumulative system in the structure of retirement scheme financing. The optimal part of the accumulative system amounting to 79.5% of the total system is determined to be the level at which the pension system e ciency is maximized. A neural model for predicting the pension system e cacy under the influence of labor market indicators is built. The size of the minimum required annual payroll deductions from the wages of persons working according to the accumulative system is calculated depending on the length of service; this minimum size ensures a replacement rate of 40% with regard to the optimal ratio of the accumulative and solidarity pension systems. These findings will be useful to state bodies when developing and clarifying directions for reforming the pension system in Kazakhstan.